Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Causes of the Salem Witch Trials

In my Language Arts class, I wrote a research report on the Salem witch trials. I've been instructed to create a multimedia version of my report, so I chose to make a power point and a blog.

This blog will discuss the possible causes of the hysteria relating to the Salem witch trials and the fuel that kept it going. If you would kindly leave your comments and/or your opinions on any of the theories and ideas I write, it would be greatly appreciated! Please keep in mind, this is based on my research report, not my personal ideas.

If you are new to the Salem witch trials you can refer to this power point I made on its history: http://docs.google.com/leaf?id=0B5t2rG6mf9FNNzgxOGIwNTktYzI1Mi00OTMzLTliZTctNGZmN2EwMTZiMGYx&hl=en


Causes:

  • Theories as to what triggered the hysteria in Salem have been offered by Linda Caporael, Laurie Winn Carlson, and George W. Hudler to name a few. Caporael suggests ergot was the cause for the hunt. This is a poisonous fungus that can grow on rye, which was used to make bread. It was also the main crop at the time, so this is possible. The symptoms include delusions, involuntary movement of the body, hallucinations, and sometimes death. All of which coincide with the symptoms of the "victims".
  • Laurie Winn Carlson, however, disagrees with Caporael. She proposes the idea of a disease called encephalitis, a swelling of the brain brought on by a virus carried by mosquitoes. Carlson argues that the ergot fungus arises when there is a lack of vitamin A in a diet, yet the society thrived on milk and seafood.
  • George W. Hudler puts forward a combination of the two former theories. He says, "I buy parts of [the ergot theory]. I think that the symptoms of ergot poisoning could have initiated the episode. At the same time, I think some adolescent hysteria probably fed on some of those episodes too."

Fuel:

  • The Salem community was strictly Puritan when it originated. Their belief consisted of God's supreme authority over human affairs. Whenever something went wrong, such as illness or death, a sin must have been committed (in their mind-set). If the witches were the cause of their misfortune, it contradicted their belief. Does God not care enough to give the people a warning of their bad decisions before consequences are met? This theory isn't generally accepted, because why would Puritans start to think of misfortune as a sign of witchcraft, rather than a sign from God?
  • Or, was the witch hunt embraced by Puritans because it was a sign from God to return to their previously strict way life? This would mean that instead of the trials being a main event, it was part of a greater purpose. Witches were then not the ones inflicting adversity, but rather an aspect of it.

10 comments:

  1. this is some good stuff

    ReplyDelete
  2. I saw the power point and I thought it was awesome. it was really informative and gave alot of details that i never knew of. great job ;]

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have heard about Witch Hunts and one thing that amazed me was the way in which someone was determined to be a witch. One determination was to throw the victim in a body of water and if they lived, they were then labeled as a witch. If they drown, it was determined they were not a witch, but unfortunately, they still lost their life. Witch hunts should have been swept away.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I believe that how some people thought others were witches is ridiculous. How can someone even determine something like that? Also, I believe that God doesn't cause people to be ill or get a disease, and just because someone is sick doesn't mean that they did anything wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  5. People always seem to be so focused on religion back in those days because science had its limits. It seems very logical that both the fungus and the disease are very plausible ideas, but did anyone notice how there all women?Mabe it was just a way to control women. "You washed my white shirt with my red shirt and it turned pink and is unmanly now!!!!!! WITCH!!!!!!"

    ReplyDelete
  6. I concur with Rachel! I can understand that there is a great possibility that both the fungus and disease could have been the cause but I do find it ironic that they have all been females. Could it be possible that there were actually cases of men with "witch fever" but excuses were made justifying their behavior?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great report! Everything happens for a reason. God's will.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is an incredible report. Just the right length for a quick read yet loaded with very concise information on such an interesting time in our history.

    The potential causes for the behaviors that led to being accused of witchcraft are details you rarely see in stories on this subject.

    Very well done!!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Actually, men were included in the accusations of witchcraft.
    Giles Corey was in his eighties when he was convicted and was crushed to death when he wouldn't confess to the craft.
    Also, John Proctor was hanged after being accused by several of the women in his life.

    Thank you all for your input!
    ~Coralia

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thefishmarket, The fish market is the only website where you can order Seafood Online. The Dry Fish will be shipped from Mangalore Karnataka, through India Post. The Fish Market covered prawns, seafood, dry seafood Online, Sea Food, the seafood markets, Sea Food markets Online, Buy Dry Fish Online, buy dried fish online, dried fish, Sea Food Online, Dry Fish, Buy Dry Fish.

    ReplyDelete